skip to Main Content

Your Strategic Plan Isn’t the Problem. Your Sales Team’s Ability to Execute It Might Be.

 

Why Does the No Smoke And Mirrors Strategic Planning Process Start With A Sales Effectiveness Assessment?

 

Most strategic plans don’t fail because the strategy was wrong. They fail because the organization writing it was never capable of executing it in the first place, and nobody stopped to check before the plan went final and was launched at the SKO. That’s one of the harder lessons I’ve learned working with B2B companies trying to scale, and it’s the one leadership teams resist hearing the most, because it often means the problem isn’t the market, the competition, or the plan on the page. It’s a question nobody asked before they started writing

Do your salespeople have the skills, beliefs, and motivations to execute our strategic plan?

In my book, Driving Explosive Growth, I lay out the No Smoke & Mirrors™ process for strategically scaling a company, and at its center sits one simple rule: don’t start strategic planning by writing the strategy. Start by gathering the facts. Before you decide where the company should go, you need to understand where it actually stands today its current state- and, more importantly, whether the people responsible for getting you there can actually do it.

Data Before Strategy Planning: The Foundation of The No Smoke and Mirrors Strategic Growth Process.

I believe the pre-planning process has to start with real data, not assumptions, gut, or intuition. That means honestly looking at what customers tell you about their needs, frustrations, buying criteria, and plans. It means reviewing actual transaction data—what customers are really buying, how often, and at what margin. It means understanding net profit by customer and by rep, so you know who and what is actually producing profitable growth versus just revenue that looks good on a slide. It means studying the industry trends in technology, competition, regulation, pricing, and customer behavior that could reshape the business regardless of what you decide to do. It also means honestly assessing sales effectiveness: does the team in front of you have the skills required to execute the growth strategy you’re about to write down?

That last piece gets skipped constantly, and it might be the most important one on the list.

Your Strategy Is Only as Strong as Your Sales Team’s Ability to Execute It

Picture a company that decides its strategic priority for the next three years is dramatically increasing revenue from its existing customer base. On paper, that’s a perfectly reasonable strategy. Organic growth is something every company should include in its plans because it is much quicker and more profitable than growth through new logos. Plenty of good companies have grown exactly that way.

Then you actually assess the sales organization, and you discover something the whiteboard session at the two-day retreat never accounted for: you have a team of hunters.

They’re genuinely good at finding new prospects, opening doors cold, and winning brand-new accounts. They are not particularly strong at account planning, cross-selling, upselling, retention, executive relationship development, strategic account management, or expanding wallet share inside an account they already own.

You don’t have a strategy problem. You have an execution capability problem, and those are two completely different sales problems to fix. If the plan quietly assumes this same team will suddenly become world-class account managers just because the strategy needs them to, that plan was built on an assumption and a wish instead of evidence. That’s exactly the kind of smoke and mirrors the whole process is designed to eliminate.

The Strategic Plan Decision You Actually Have to Make

Here is the fork in the road, and it’s the one thing I want every leadership team to sit with before they finalize anything. Once you know your team can’t yet execute the plan as written, you have exactly two real options, and pretending otherwise is how good strategies quietly die in year one.

Option one: delay the strategic plan launch and train the team first.

You keep the strategic plan as written because it’s the right plan for where the business genuinely needs to go, and you accept that there’s a real runway of training, coaching, and skill development that has to happen before the team can execute it credibly. This costs you time up front. It buys you a plan that actually has a chance of working when it launches, instead of one that stumbles out of the gate and quietly gets blamed on “execution” a year later when the real issue was readiness. The risk is that market conditions change, and you may miss a market opportunity to scale now.

Option two: build the plan around what your team can execute today, while you train them toward where you eventually want to be.

You don’t abandon the bigger ambition. You sequence it. You write a nearer-term plan your current team can genuinely run with the skills they have right now, and you build the training and hiring investment in parallel, so the plan you write eighteen months from now can finally reach for what this one couldn’t.

Neither option is wrong. What’s wrong is doing neither — writing the ambitious plan anyway, handing it to a team that isn’t ready, and hoping the gap closes itself somewhere in Q2. It won’t. It never has, in any company I’ve worked with. I have heard over and over again as the CRO or VP of Sales …” Figure It Out.“

The Sales Team’s Sales Effectiveness Today Changes the Strategic Plan

Now picture a different company. This sales team is made up of excellent farmers with deep relationships with existing customers, genuinely strong at retention and account expansion. Or, as I often find with B2B manufacturers and their distributors, brilliant engineers who lack sales skills. They struggle with prospecting, cold outreach, new-logo acquisition, and creating opportunity with companies that don’t already know them. Would you hand this team the same growth-through-new-logo strategy you’d hand the hunters? Of course not, and yet I watch companies do exactly that all the time, simply because the strategy looked good in the boardroom.

If growth through new logos is the plan, and your team currently has low prospecting skills, your strategic plan will place more emphasis and budget on marketing.

There’s a third pattern I see often enough that I’ve started calling it farmers and fishermen: reps who are comfortable working their existing territory and relationships; if a lead comes in, they will reel it in to a close, but who aren’t consistently out hunting the large new opportunities the plan actually requires. The same lesson applies. The strategic plan has to reflect the reality of the team you have today, not the team you wish you had.

The question was never “what do we want our salespeople to do?”

The better question, every time, is “what are our salespeople actually capable of doing right now, and what capabilities do we need to build to get from here to the plan?”

That’s a fundamentally different planning conversation, and it’s the one most companies skip.

What a Real Sales Effectiveness Assessment Actually Measures

This is why I believe a genuine sales effectiveness assessment belongs in the pre-planning process, not as an afterthought once the strategy is already written. You need to understand what the team can do today before you build a plan that quietly assumes they already can. Our sales effectiveness assessment covers 21 sales skills, beliefs, and motivations. We review the client’s selling environment, management strategy, and systems, processes, and sales tools. We measure sales manager skills and how aligned sales managers are with the sales leader’s vision. This sales assessment is not a personality test; it has over 90% predictive validity for sales roles.

A real sales effectiveness assessment looks at whether the team can consistently create new opportunities through prospecting, not just occasionally when the pipeline runs dry. It looks at discovery—can they uncover a business problem, the priorities behind it, the financial impact, and a genuine reason for the customer to change? It looks at value selling, the difference between articulating real business value and simply presenting features. It looks at executive selling—whether reps can hold a credible conversation with a decision-maker instead of getting stuck one level below them. It looks at account management discipline, whether existing accounts get systematically grown or just quietly serviced. It looks at negotiation, whether a rep can protect price and margin while still creating real value instead of discounting to keep the peace.

It looks at pipeline management and whether the team creates enough genuinely qualified pipeline to support the growth number leadership actually wants. It looks at closing, whether opportunities get real forward commitment or linger. And increasingly, it has to look at whether reps can navigate a complex, multi-stakeholder buying process, because that’s the environment strategic selling actually happens in today, not the one-champion sale most training was built around a decade ago. Finally, it looks at CRM discipline and whether what’s in the system reflects reality, or just optimism dressed up as a forecast.

Once completed, the sales effectiveness assessment gives leadership something genuinely valuable: an honest picture of the organization’s current execution capability, not the capability the strategy hopes it has.

 

What Can The Sales Team Do, and What Will They Actually Do It?

There’s a second distinction worth making, because it’s just as important as raw skill: an assessment tells you not just what your salespeople can do, but what they’re likely to do, consistently, without a manager standing over them. Strategy requires behavior, not just capability. We need to understand the sales team’s beliefs and motivations.

If the plan requires twenty new prospecting calls a week, but the current sales culture has spent years rewarding account service instead, and your reps have never built a prospecting habit, putting that number on a scorecard doesn’t make the strategy executable overnight.

If the strategy depends on selling to CEOs but your sales reps are visibly uncomfortable in that room, that’s a real capability gap, not a motivation problem a pep talk fixes.

If the plan calls for larger, more complex opportunities but the team has spent its whole career on transactional deals, that’s another gap the plan has to account for honestly, not one it can wish away with a bigger number on the whiteboard.

No Smoke Advice: Don’t Build a Three-Year Plan on a One-Year Assumption (or Capabilities Fantasy)

One of the most common mistakes leadership teams make in planning is assuming the organization they want is the organization they already have. They build the plan around future capabilities without ever naming the actual gap between today and that future. That’s backward, every time.

The right order is simple, even if it’s rarely followed: understand the current state honestly first. Then clearly define the desired future state. Then name the actual capability gap between the two, specifically, not vaguely. Only then build the strategy, investment, hiring, training, coaching, technology, and accountability system required to close that exact gap. Do it in that order, and you have a strategy with a real chance of becoming reality instead of another deck filed away by month three.

Strategic Planning Should Follow the Sense-Making Process

This is where the No Smoke & Mirrors approach actually begins: gather the data, make honest sense of it, identify the real gaps, understand the actual capability of the people who have to execute, and only then build the strategy. Not the other way around.

Your strategic plan was never meant to exist independently of your people. Build it around them, because even the best strategy in the world doesn’t execute itself. People execute strategy. If you don’t genuinely understand the capability of the people responsible for that execution, you’re taking on serious risk before the plan is even finished being written, and no amount of polish on the final deck changes that.

Before You Ask “Where Are We Going?”
Ask “What Can We Actually Execute Right Now?”

Before your next strategic planning session, resist the instinct to book the off-site and start filling whiteboards with three-year revenue targets. Start with an honest assessment instead. Talk to your customers with voice-of-customer interviews. Look hard at the transaction data. Understand real profit by customer and by rep.

Study what’s actually shifting in your market. Understand your current excess capacity and how long it may take to ramp up to meet your strategic plan goals. And assess sales effectiveness honestly, not generously.

Then ask what the data is actually telling you, what capabilities genuinely exist today, what capabilities are missing, and what has to change for the strategy actually to work in practice, not just on paper. Only then finalize the plan — and when you find the gap, as you almost certainly will, make the real decision instead of avoiding it: do you delay the launch and train the team first, or do you build a plan your team can execute today while you train them toward the bigger one.

A brilliant strategic growth plan your sales team can’t execute isn’t really a strategy. It’s a wish with a deadline attached. Eliminating that kind of wishful thinking is the entire point of the No Smoke & Mirrors™ process.
Let’s schedule a call to discuss how the No Smoke & Mirrors strategic planning process can drive explosive growth.
Back To Top